Your Child and Autism

Oppressive Disability Policy Clauses Outlawed; Major Boon To Disabled Persons

Many disabled persons have been denied long term disability benefits under their employers? disability plans because the insurance policies funding the plans gave the administrators nearly unfettered discretion to decide whether a person is disabled or not. With insurers getting to decide whether to pay or not, with little risk of being overruled, it is no wonder that insurers have done what is best for themselves, deny claims.

Now insurance policies issued in several states, including Michigan, funding those disability plans are prohibited from including the onerous ?discretionary? clauses that give the plan administrators such power to reject claims.

Most recently federal courts in Michigan and Montana rejected insurance industry?s challenges to the insurance department rulings, including Michigan administrative rules issued in February 2007 by the State of Michigan Office of Financial & Insurance Services and rulings by the Montana Department of Insurance which prohibited disability and health insurers from including discretionary clauses in their policies.

These rulings come after other State Insurance Departments such as California, Utah, Maryland, and Indiana, prohibited such clauses and after the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) adopted a model health insurance code prohibiting those provisions. Several states have adopted this model code including Maine, Oregon, and Maryland.

Why is this so important? Disability plans issued by employers as an employee benefit plan fall under the regulation of the Employee Retirement Security Act of 1974 (ERISA). Under the case law developed for ERISA, if a benefit plan contains a discretionary clause, the decision of the plan administrator is upheld unless the claimant can show that the decision was arbitrary and capricious, a very difficult task for the disabled person. If there is any reasonable basis or information to support an insurer?s denial of a claim, it will be upheld by the court. This is like starting with 2 outs and 2 strikes against you in the bottom of the ninth inning.

By eliminating discretionary clauses the courts are permitted to make a ?de novo? review of all of the evidence of disability. That means it can decide whether the person is disabled or not based on all the evidence without giving the insurer such a big advantage by presuming their decision was right if there was any evidence to support it.

It is likely that the insurance industry will appeal the Michigan and Montana federal court rulings and will continue to challenge similar rulings by State Insurance Departments and courts as there is much at stake for both the insurers and disabled persons.

Endnotes:

1. Examples of Discretionary Clauses include:

a.?. . . we have the full and exclusive authority to control and manage the Group Policy and resolve all questions arising in the administration, interpretation, and application of the Group Policy.

Our authority includes, but is not limited to:

. . .

3.The right to determine: . . . b.Entitlement to benefits; c.The amount of benefits payable; and d.The sufficiency and the amount of information we may reasonably require to determine a., b., or c. above.? [Standard Insurance Co. policy].

b.?When making a benefit determination under the policy, UNUM has discretionary authority to determine your eligibility for benefits and to interpret the terms and provisions of the policy.?

2.American Council of Life Insurers, et al v. Linda A. Walters, ____ F. Supp. 2d ____, 2008 WL 541654 (2/29/08 W.D. Mich).. Standard Insurance Co. v. Morrison, ____ F. Supp. 2d ____, 2008 WL510053 (D. Mont., 2/27/08).

3.Michigan Administrative Rules 500.2201-2202 and 550.111-112, issued 2/23/07 and effective June 1, 2007.

Evan Zagoria of Provizer & Phillips, P.C., http://www.AskEvan.net; (800) 399-EVAN (3826)has spent his entire 30+ year career handling social security and other disability matters. He is a former attorney for the Social Security Administration and is a member of the Board of N.O.S.S.C.R.

MORE ARTICLES:

The UCLA Semel Institute Reception Celebrates the Launch of The Help Group - UCLA Autism Research Alliance
This spirited occasion was hosted by Dr. Peter C. Whybrow, Director, Division of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, Semel Insititute for Neuroscience & Human Behavior, and Dr. James McCracken, Director, Division of Child & Adolescent Psychiatry, Semel Insititute for Neuroscience & Human Behavior. The event was attended by UCLA and The Help Group colleagues, faculty and friends and took place at the Semel Institute in Westwood.

Applying for Disability Benefits? Let the Battle Begin!
Ever since our childish squabbles with bullies in our schools, we have known that it is quite difficult to launch a battle with someone bigger than we are. However, if we look back in the pages of history, even in mythological stories and fairy tales, we can learn a thing or two about fighting epic battles.

Signs and Symptoms of Autism
Parents or caregivers are usually the first ones to notice the signs and symptoms of autism in a child under three years of age. At birth, the signs and symptoms of autism are not necessarily noticeable, and it may take a little while to distinguish the behavior.

Cambridge Who’s Who Recognizes Maria Calcagni for Efforts to Raise Autism Awareness
Autism Speaks volunteer leader works to resolve issues.

Kazmierczak and Kazmierczak known for its Social Security Disability Work Launches Veterans Disability Lawyer Site; Provides Information on Veterans C
The law firm of Kazmierczak and Kazmierczak has released its second informational website. The Veterans Disability Lawyer Site provides free information on veterans disability including pension and compensation. The website also discuss new law that will change the VA process forever.

Railroad Workers Are Also Entitled To Disability Benefits
Railroad work can be hard and dangerous and can result in injury or disability. But railroad workers can also become disabled for other reasons such as illness or disease not related to an on the job injury.

Los Angeles Disability Insurance Lawyers: Easing Up on People With Disability
Since the disability program of the Social Security Administration (SSA) was initiated, the disabled workers have found an alternative way to make money. Without work, it is impossible for the disabled to survive and cope with the cost of daily living including expenses for regular hospitalization needs and medicines.

A Spiritual View Of Autism
The value of a spiritual view of autism is that it enables the pain of limitation and helplessness suffered by those who experience significant impairment and those who care for them to be held within a sense of purposefulness and meaning. This can support individuals and families with a sense of truth and love, even during times of greatest challenge.

The Help Group Summit 2007 Features More Than 20 Leading Experts in Autism, Learning Disabilities & ADHD
Two-Day seminar for professionals and parents to present cutting edge information in research and best practices.